Kimberly Quinn as Donna | Then
Donna was Alan’s ex-girlfriend who was dumped due to Alan’s boredom. Donna first met Alan in a blind date, hitting it off pretty well. hysterical after he breaks it off.
It wasn’t long until Alan started to get tired of her company. Not wanting to hurt her feelings, Alan asks advice from Charlie on how to not dump Donna harshly. Unfortunately, Charlie’s advice didn’t suffice, leaving Donna completely Kimberly
Missi Pyle as Miss Pasternak | Then
Charlie, apparently, didn’t have any kind of limit when it came to women. Not even for his elementary school teacher! Miss Pasternak was Charlie’s fifth-grade teacher who suspended Jake for giving her the finger. The two shockingly began dating, with Miss Pasternak lifting his suspension and even giving him good grades without rightfully earning them!
When Charlie realized that she was mentally ill though, he ended up dumping her.
Missi Pyle as Miss Pasternak | Now
Andrea Kay Pyle, or more popularly known as Missi Pyle, is an actress and singer has appeared in several films, including some award-winning films such as The Artist, Big Fish, 50 First Dates, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, and Gone Girl. Yup, absolute blockbusters!
The actress maintaining her successful career, working on many projects that are currently in the post-production process. We’ll surely be seeing her frequently on the big screen!
Quinn as Donna | Now
Kimberly Quinn is an all-around powerhouse, engaging in acting, writing, producing, directing, and co-founding films with her husband, writer-director, Theodore Melfi. She has proved to be as much of a force behind the camera as she is in front of it.
The talented starlet can soon be seen starring opposite Vincent D’Onofrio, Dax Shepard, Jessica Alba, and Tim Allen in her next feature film, “El Camino Christmas”.
Justine Eyre as Gabrielle | Then
Gabrielle was Charlie’s girlfriend up until Alan decided to steal her. Apparently, Alan was seeking revenge after finding out that it was Charlie who stole his high school lover from him. Charlie obviously reacts badly, expressing that he felt betrayed by his own brother. In regret, Alan apologizes and says he will give her back, but Charlie thinks it’s too late.
Though the two keep seeing each other, Alan eventually feels uncomfortable and goes home. Upon coming home, he sees Charlie with Charity who deviously tells Alan, “now we’re even”. Burn!