Evans and Rossum met a week before they were seen in that bar. They were never seen together again since, however, Emmy Rossum’s name is listed, among others, on Evans’s dating history.
Was there more going on that no one knows about? Could there have been more secret dates in dark bars that no one is aware of? Who knows…
Alba Baptista — Today
So, who did Alba Baptista date before she began seeing Evans? Alba was born in 1997, making her 16 years younger than Evans, so her dating history is much more modest than his.
The only known relationship Alba is associated with is the one with Kristina Tonteri-Young. This may only be a rumor as nothing has ever been confirmed, however, we like to believe that the two brought some of their on-screen magic off-screen into reality.
Way back in 2007, before Lily James, Lily Collins, or Baptista came into the picture, Evans met Emmy Rossum. They were seen with hands all over one another in the famous Hollywood nightclub "Teddy's," and even after evidence of the two was presented, they still denied the romance.
The American actress never gave any more details about what was going on, so we can assume it was a one-off thing.
Emmy Rossum — Today
Emmy Rossum has a rich dating history too. Between 2005 and 2007, it was reported that she was seeing Topher Grace, however, they managed to keep things private. In 2007, she was seen making out with Milo Ventimiglia.
Then in 2009, it was discovered that she was married to Justin Siegel, and no one knew about it. He divorced her a year after they tied the knot. In 2017 she married Sam Esmail, and in 2021, she gave birth to her daughter, a pregnancy she managed to keep a secret too.
Chris Evans and Kristin Cavallari were seen leaving a party in Miami together, and the two seemed pretty close to one another. Later, Cavallari denied anything romantic was going on between them and that they were only good friends.
She told US Weekly, “I've known Chris for a while, just through mutual friends. We're just friends.” She explained that she met Evans through other friends, and it was all innocent.