Evans never contributes any information whenever asked about what happened that night, and like many other lovers on this list, it might as well have been just a friendly night out.
Amy Smart, on her side, has not denied and not confirmed any detail about that evening, so we believe that there could very well be some truth behind these speculations.
Kristin Cavallari — Today
Cavallari has been seen with Hollywood stars, big NFL names, and even some anonymous dudes no one knows about. In 2004, she dated Stephen Colletti, and a few years later, she was involved with two more reality celebs — Talan Torriero and Mat Leinart.
On April 2013, Kristin married her big love, Jay Cutler. Ten years later, they decided to go their separate ways, and for now, she is adjusting to being alone for a moment.
In 2010, Chris Evans and Amy Smart were seen in London, England, leaving the Cirque club. He was 29 years old at the time, and Smart was 34. Evans was seen pushing his way through the crowd and hopping into a van that was awaiting him.
This was the only time Smart and Evans were seen together, however, there is evidence that the night didn't end there and that the two had something on.
Amy Smart — Today
The American actress has made it big. She is best known for starring in "The Butterfly Effect" and "Just Friends." Her name has been related to Ashton Kutcher and Branden Williams, and she has been married to Carter Oosterhouse since 2011.
Smart is known to hold long and strong relationships. Her first true love (Williams) lasted for almost 15 years, and she's planning on being with Oosterhouse for the rest of her life.
Some may say that Dodger is presumably Chris Evans' real and only true love. Evans had said on a number of occasions that the relationship between him and Dodger is pure love, unconditional and endless. He even has a tattoo of his name.
Dodger, named after a favorite character in the movie "Oliver & Company," is a rescue dog Evans adopted in 2017. At the time, Evans was filming a scene for the movie "Gifted," and he just couldn't take his eye off the adorable puppy.