How it all began
The actor first met Brandy when she was cast as his love interest in the film “I Still Know What You Did Last Summer”. A few weeks before the film started shooting, Brandy approached Phifer and offered him the role of the boy in the music video.
Brandy and Monica had a less-than-friendly relationship according to the tabloids, although Monica claims it was all for marketing’s sake. Pheifer, however, took no sides in the supposed feud.
In a 2019 interview, Dallas Austin, who produced the song, said things between the two singers were so bad they even escalated into a punch thrown in Brandy’s face by Monica. Pheifer’s recollection of the incident is a little different. According to him, there was tension on the filming set. He speculates that the friction was because of the status difference between Monica, who was pretty new and unfamiliar ar the time, and Brandy, who’d had a well-established career as an actress and singer.
In the end, does it even matter?
Those of you who watched the video probably remember the open ending, not conclusively placing the guy with any of the girls. In an interview with Entertainment Weekly, Pheifer said he has no idea what the end would be like if they shot it now. “Did I choose one over the other? Or did they both call me a cheater and say, ‘Get away from me!’ Who knows?”
Back then, Pheifer was in his early 20s, and according to him, acted pretty similar to his character in the video. Thankfully, he grew out of this phase, and now says he is more mature, more focused, and happily married.